StrategyRental › Prop firms › Boxcar vs BluSky
Boxcar or BluSky? A comparison for our automated strategies
Both prop firms allow our automated strategies for NinjaTrader 8. Here you will find their programs, evaluation and payout rules, what everything costs, our discount codes and a hypothetical simulation of our SRzona strategy on both firms – all in one place.
- Discount codes
- How it works
- Programs
- Rules side by side
- What you pay
- SRzona simulation
- Example
- Launch or Orbit
- More accounts
- Which is better
In short
- In the hypothetical SRzona simulation (1 ES contract), the average account earned the most on BluSky Launch 50K: +$6,793 after prop firm fees and the SRzona rental. On Boxcar Flex 50K: +$3,699 (accounts started from May 20, 2025 to Aug 6, 2026, measured fills).
- BluSky Launch 50K also came out best for accounts started from March 2026 (+$6,644, worst case +$4,866). In the strictest view over the whole period, however, Boxcar Flex 150K came out best (+$4,308) and BluSky Launch 50K only +$1,797.
- Boxcar: you pay once, nothing monthly, a free VPS and written permission for our strategies. BluSky Launch: a cheap start with a monthly fee only during the evaluation, and from the funded account you can withdraw all profit above the buffer (up to $2,500 per 7 days); at $10,000 total profit, however, the account is reviewed for a live account.
- The simulation counts one account. A trader who opens another account after one ends, or runs several at once – even a Boxcar and BluSky combination – can get more out of the prop firms – for example accounts one after another from Jan 2, 2026: Boxcar Flex 50K +$16,160, BluSky Launch 50K +$14,234 (measured fills, after all fees). More accounts
- The choice is yours. This is not a recommendation or a guarantee of results – these are hypothetical results on past data.
Our discount codes
Enter the code in the cart when you buy. You will see the discount before you pay.
Boxcar Trading
- When you buy, you can add a free Chicago VPS.
- Boxcar program prices are in the table below.
BluSky Trading
- Discounts according to BluSky: Orbit −30%, Propel −30%, Launch −$10, Instant Funding −$300.
Partner codes and links: if you buy through them, we earn a commission.
How a prop firm account works
First you pay for an evaluation on a simulated account. When you reach the profit target without hitting the loss limit, you get a simulated funded account. The firm pays you 90% of its profit. Later the firm may move you to a live account.
- Evaluation (challenge)
- You need to reach a profit target, for example $3,000 on a 50K account. Trades are simulated; you only pay the evaluation fee.
- Loss limit
- The level your balance must not fall to. At both firms it moves up with the highest end-of-day balance (trailing). If the balance reaches it during trading, even with an open loss, the account fails.
- Consistency
- Your best day may make up at most a certain share of the profit, so the profit does not come from a single day.
- Buffer
- BluSky Launch and Propel only: after the evaluation you need to earn $3,000 once more (50K). This money is not paid out – it is the cushion of the funded account.
- Funded account
- A simulated account; the firm pays you 90% of its profit. Trades do not go to the exchange.
- Payout
- The money you withdraw from the funded account. Each firm has a minimum, a cap and conditions for when you can request one.
- Live account
- A real brokerage account. The move is not automatic; the firm decides.
Programs
Boxcar Trading – 4 programs
| Program | Evaluation | Funded account and payouts | Price 50K | For our strategies |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BoxcarFlex | Target $3,000, loss limit $2,000. Consistency 40% or 50% (chosen at purchase). | No consistency and no buffer. Payout after 5 days with at least $150 profit, up to 50% of the account profit, max $2,000. | from $80 $130 with 50% and no daily loss limit | SRzona, Range Breakout, Euro Open NQ (150K) |
| BoxcarPrime | Target $3,000, loss limit $2,000, no consistency. | Cycle +$500, best day max 40% of the cycle profit. First payout max $2,000, then $2,500; $52,100 stays in the account. | from $120 with daily loss limit | Range Breakout, Trend Pullback NQ (150K), Euro Open NQ (150K) |
| BoxcarPayout | Configurable evaluation (end-of-day or intraday loss limit, 40% / 50%). | Intraday loss limit, payouts even daily. The funded account must be flat around major US news. | $85 default settings | Do not choose – our strategies also trade around news. |
| BoxcarFunded | No evaluation – funded right away. | First cycle target $3,000, best day max 20% of the cycle profit, payouts 1–3 max $2,000, then $2,500. | $360 | Not simulated. |
Common to Boxcar: one-time payment, no monthly fees and no activation fee; 90% split; with Flex, Prime and Funded at most 5 payouts per simulated account, then a review for a live account. Prices from the Boxcar website on Nov 6, 2026 (with the discount Boxcar currently shows there).
BluSky – 4 programs
| Program | Evaluation | Funded account and payouts | Price 50K | For our strategies |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Launch | Target $3,000, loss limit $2,000, best day max $1,500, at least 2 profitable days. Then a $3,000 Buffer (best day max $1,020). | Starts at $3,000, fails at $100. Payouts every weekday from profit above $3,000, min $500, max $2,500 per 7 days. | $59 / 30 days + $99 after passing | SRzona |
| Propel | Target $3,000, loss limit $2,000, consistency 34%. Then a $3,000 Buffer. | Starts at $3,000, payouts every weekday from profit above the buffer, min $500. | $160 / 30 days | Not simulated. |
| Orbit | Target $3,000, loss limit $2,000, no consistency. The evaluation is valid for 30 days from purchase. | Starts at $50,000, you withdraw only the amount above $52,000, every 3 trading days, max $2,000 per week, best day max 40%. | $199 one-time | Worse than Launch in the SRzona simulation – see below. |
| Instant Funding | No evaluation. | Intraday loss limit $2,000, daily limit $1,000, consistency 21%, 80% split. | $599 one-time | Not simulated. |
For both Launch and Orbit: at $10,000 total profit you must stop trading and BluSky reviews a move to a live account. Prices from the BluSky website on Nov 6, 2026, without discount. We state the Launch evaluation consistency according to their rules (best day max $1,500 = 50%); the pricing card on their website shows 55%.
Boxcar Flex vs BluSky Launch: rules side by side
These are the two programs we simulated with SRzona. Values for a 50K account:
| Boxcar Flex 50K | BluSky Launch 50K | |
|---|---|---|
| Evaluation price | $130 once (50% consistency, no daily loss limit) | $59 every 30 days, only until you pass |
| After passing | nothing | $99 (pay within 14 days) |
| Evaluation target | $3,000 | $3,000 |
| Evaluation loss limit | $2,000 below the highest end-of-day balance; stops at $50,100 | $2,000 below the highest end-of-day balance |
| Evaluation consistency | best day max 52% of profit | best day max $1,500, at least 2 profitable days |
| Time limit | none (inactivity rule applies) | none, but you pay every 30 days |
| Extra step | none | Buffer: another $3,000, limit $2,000, best day max $1,020; not paid out, nothing to pay |
| Funded account – loss limit | $2,000 below the highest end-of-day balance; locks at $50,100 after the first payout request | starts at $3,000, fails at $100 (fixed level) |
| When you can request a payout | after 5 days with at least $150 profit in the cycle, cycle in profit | every weekday from profit above $3,000; at least +$500 of new profit between payouts |
| How much at once | up to 50% of the whole account profit, min $500, max $2,000 | min $500, max $2,500 per 7 days |
| Your split | 90% | 90% |
| End of the simulated account | at most 5 payouts, then a review for a live account (may come earlier); remaining simulated profit is forfeited, the live account starts at $0 | at $10,000 total profit: stop and review for a live account |
| Contracts | evaluation max 4 minis; funded 2 minis until profit reaches $1,000 | evaluation max 5 minis; funded based on balance |
Larger accounts
| Boxcar Flex 100K | Boxcar Flex 150K | BluSky Launch 100K | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $215 once | $295 once | $69 / 30 days + $149 after passing |
| Evaluation target | $6,000 | $9,000 | $6,000 |
| Loss limit | $3,000 | $4,500 | $2,500 |
| Buffer | – | – | $3,500 (best day max $1,190) |
| Payout | 5 days with at least $200 profit, max $2,500 | 5 days with at least $250 profit, max $3,000 | max $3,000 per 7 days |
BluSky has no 150K account in the Launch program.
What you pay for what
| Boxcar Flex 50K | BluSky Launch 50K | BluSky Orbit 50K | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evaluation | $130 once | $59 every 30 days during the evaluation | $199 once, valid 30 days |
| With our code | you will see the price in the cart | −$10 according to BluSky | −30% according to BluSky |
| After passing | $0 | $99 | $0 |
| Buffer and funded account | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| If the account fails | evaluation reset at the price of a new account; a funded account cannot be reset – new evaluation | evaluation reset $49 (free when the subscription renews); Buffer reset $250 | reset $129 (does not extend the 30 days) |
| Extras | free Chicago VPS while you have an active paid account; trading platform included in the plan; ES commission $3.50 per trade | NinjaTrader 8 via Rithmic; check that your country is allowed | same as Launch |
Plus the rental of our strategy: SRzona free for 10 days, then €99 per month for the first 3 months and €199 per month after that, cancel anytime. Each additional account at half price: €49 for its first 3 months, even if you add it later, then €99. The simulation below deducts the rental for one account.
Simulation: where SRzona earned more
HypotheticalOn every trading day from May 20, 2025 to Aug 6, 2026 we opened a new hypothetical account on past data and let it trade SRzona (1 ES contract) under the firm's rules – 298 start days for each program. Each account traded until it failed or ended under the firm's rules, at the latest until the end of the data on Oct 30, 2026. “From 3/2026” = only accounts started from March 2, 2026. Below is the average per account: payouts (your 90% split) minus prop firm fees and minus the SRzona rental.
| Program | Payouts (90%) | Prop firm fees | SRzona rental | Net result | Accounts in profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boxcar Flex 50K | $4,186 | −$130 | −$356 | +$3,699 | 98% |
| Boxcar Flex 100K | $4,678 | −$215 | −$583 | +$3,881 | 90% |
| Boxcar Flex 150K | $6,251 | −$295 | −$853 | +$5,103 | 87% |
| BluSky Launch 50K | $7,778 | −$189 | −$796 | +$6,793 | 100% |
| BluSky Launch 100K | $7,302 | −$332 | −$944 | +$6,027 | 97% |
Average per hypothetical account, 298 start days. Accounts in profit = share of start days where payouts exceeded both the fees and the rental.
| Program | Payouts (90%) | Prop firm fees | SRzona rental | Net result | Accounts in profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boxcar Flex 50K | $6,114 | −$130 | −$279 | +$5,706 | 100% |
| Boxcar Flex 100K | $6,328 | −$215 | −$388 | +$5,725 | 100% |
| Boxcar Flex 150K | $6,170 | −$295 | −$546 | +$5,328 | 92% |
| BluSky Launch 50K | $7,216 | −$166 | −$405 | +$6,644 | 100% |
| BluSky Launch 100K | $6,307 | −$268 | −$540 | +$5,499 | 92% |
Average per hypothetical account, 112 start days. Accounts in profit = share of start days where payouts exceeded both the fees and the rental.
| Program | Payouts (90%) | Prop firm fees | SRzona rental | Net result | Accounts in profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boxcar Flex 50K | $1,514 | −$130 | −$285 | +$1,099 | 49% |
| Boxcar Flex 100K | $4,026 | −$215 | −$967 | +$2,844 | 80% |
| Boxcar Flex 150K | $5,900 | −$295 | −$1,298 | +$4,308 | 80% |
| BluSky Launch 50K | $2,400 | −$172 | −$431 | +$1,797 | 37% |
| BluSky Launch 100K | $4,400 | −$330 | −$860 | +$3,210 | 58% |
Average per hypothetical account, 297 start days. Accounts in profit = share of start days where payouts exceeded both the fees and the rental.
| Program | Payouts (90%) | Prop firm fees | SRzona rental | Net result | Accounts in profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boxcar Flex 50K | $3,395 | −$130 | −$303 | +$2,962 | 100% |
| Boxcar Flex 100K | $2,929 | −$215 | −$455 | +$2,259 | 89% |
| Boxcar Flex 150K | $2,747 | −$295 | −$671 | +$1,780 | 64% |
| BluSky Launch 50K | $5,739 | −$181 | −$692 | +$4,866 | 92% |
| BluSky Launch 100K | $4,539 | −$313 | −$823 | +$3,403 | 68% |
Average per hypothetical account, 111 start days. Accounts in profit = share of start days where payouts exceeded both the fees and the rental.
Boxcar ends after the 5th payout and BluSky at $10,000 total profit – the firm then reviews a live account. The simulation counts only the simulated account; what a live account would bring is not in the numbers.
Example: the average hypothetical 50K account
Measured fills, average of 298 accounts started on every trading day from May 20, 2025 to Aug 6, 2026 (data until Oct 30, 2026):
Boxcar Flex 50K
98% of accounts in profit.
BluSky Launch 50K
100% of accounts in profit.
Amounts are rounded to whole dollars, so they may differ by $1.
Why BluSky comes out higher: the same payout at both firms
An illustration of the rules, not a simulation result: your 50K funded account has $3,000 of profit and meets the payout conditions.
Boxcar Flex 50K
$1,500 of profit stays in the account and the loss limit locks at $50,100. The next payout needs another 5 profitable days.
BluSky Launch 50K
The $3,000 buffer and $500 of profit stay in the account; the account fails at $100.
BluSky: Launch or Orbit?
Orbit is paid once ($199, −30% with our code) and has no Buffer stage. But you have to pass the evaluation within 30 days of purchase, and from the funded account you withdraw only the amount above $52,000, at most $2,000 per week. In the SRzona simulation Launch 50K came out better in every view:
| Measured fills | Worst case | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| whole period | from 3/2026 | whole period | from 3/2026 | |
| Launch 50K – passes the evaluation | 100% | 100% | 69% | 100% |
| Launch 50K – at least 1 payout | 100% | 100% | 37% | 92% |
| Launch 50K – payouts minus fees | +$7,604 | +$7,061 | +$2,246 | +$5,572 |
| Orbit 50K – passes within 30 days | 53% | 88% | 29% | 62% |
| Orbit 50K – at least 1 payout | 53% | 88% | 25% | 62% |
| Orbit 50K – payouts minus fee | +$2,876 | +$4,670 | +$1,266 | +$3,392 |
Average per hypothetical account, payouts (90%) minus BluSky fees, without the SRzona rental. Prices with our code according to BluSky: Launch $49 / 30 days + $99, Orbit $139.30. Both end at $10,000 total profit.
More accounts: how much you get out depends on you too
The simulation above always counts one account – from purchase until it fails or ends under the firm's rules. How much you get out of prop firms in the end also depends on how resourcefully you organize your accounts. A skilled trader does not have to stop at one account.
Example: accounts one after another from Jan 2, 2026
The client started on Jan 2, 2026 with one account. Whenever an account failed or ended under the firm's rules, he immediately bought a new one – always just one account at a time. He traded until the end of the data on Oct 30, 2026. Prop firm fees for all accounts bought and the SRzona rental for the whole time ($1,888) are deducted.
| Program | Accounts bought | Payouts (90%) | Prop firm fees | SRzona rental | Net – measured | Net – worst case |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boxcar Flex 50K | 4 (1 failed) | $18,568 | −$520 | −$1,888 | +$16,160 | +$9,308 |
| Boxcar Flex 100K | 3 (1 failed) | $15,180 | −$645 | −$1,888 | +$12,647 | +$7,736 |
| Boxcar Flex 150K | 2 (0 failed) | $15,308 | −$590 | −$1,888 | +$12,830 | +$6,479 |
| BluSky Launch 50K | 3 (0 failed) | $16,596 | −$474 | −$1,888 | +$14,234 | +$7,884 |
| BluSky Launch 100K | 2 (0 failed) | $15,579 | −$643 | −$1,888 | +$13,048 | +$6,058 |
Hypothetical. Starting on any trading day in January 2026 (20 start days), the average with measured fills is +$16,883 for Boxcar Flex 50K and +$13,987 for BluSky Launch 50K. After the 5th payout Boxcar reviews a live account: the chain holds if Boxcar does not move you – if it does, the simulated accounts are closed and what follows depends on the live account. With two accounts at once (for example Boxcar + BluSky) the payouts add up; the second SRzona account costs half.
Another account after one ends
When an account fails or ends under the rules, you buy a new one and continue. The number of evaluations is unlimited at both Boxcar and BluSky.
Several accounts at once
Boxcar allows up to 5 funded accounts at once, BluSky up to 3. All of them take the same trades, so payouts multiply – but in a weak period all accounts can fail at once.
Boxcar + BluSky combination
For example one Boxcar Flex 50K and one BluSky Launch 50K. Each account follows its own firm's rules: Boxcar you pay once, from BluSky you withdraw all profit above the buffer. You do not depend on the rules of a single firm.
Watch out for opposite positions
Both firms prohibit holding a long on one account and a short on another in the same or a similar market – Boxcar even across accounts at other firms. SRzona has a safeguard: when it runs on several accounts in one NinjaTrader, it does not send an opposite entry.
When a live account comes
When a firm moves you to a live account, its simulated accounts end: Boxcar closes the simulated accounts of the whole household, BluSky ends its Sim Funded accounts. The move is not automatic – Boxcar does not have to move you after the 5th payout. According to their websites, these rules apply only to their own accounts. That is why a combination of one Boxcar and one BluSky account is better: their rules do not end the account at the other firm.
Open the second account in time
When you see an account approaching its end – at Boxcar the 4th and 5th payout, at BluSky $10,000 total profit – open an account at the other firm in time. While it passes the evaluation, the first account is still paying out, and when that one ends, the second may already be earning.
SRzona for each additional account at half price
Main account: €99 per month for the first 3 months, then €199. Each additional account, even if you add it later: €49 per month for its first 3 months, then €99.
Which is better?
Boxcar Trading
- You pay once – no monthly or activation fees.
- Confirmed in writing that unrelated traders may use the same strategy on their own accounts.
- Free Chicago VPS, platform included.
- Larger accounts (150K with a $4,500 loss limit) and simulations for all our strategies.
- Payout up to 50% of the account profit and at most 5 payouts per account.
- When you move to a live account, the remaining simulated profit is forfeited.
BluSky
- Cheap start: $59 / 30 days, and you pay only during the evaluation.
- From the funded account you can withdraw all profit above the buffer (up to $2,500 per 7 days), even every weekday.
- In the SRzona simulation Launch 50K had the highest net result in 3 of 4 views.
- An extra $3,000 Buffer that is not paid out, and $99 after passing the evaluation.
- The funded loss limit is fixed: from $3,000 down to $100.
- At $10,000 total profit: stop and review.
Which program for which strategy
Recommendations from simulations on past data – the final choice is yours:
| Strategy | Boxcar | BluSky |
|---|---|---|
| SRzona (ES) | BoxcarFlex 50K | Launch 50K |
| Range Breakout | BoxcarPrime 50K or BoxcarFlex 50K | – |
| Trend Pullback NQ | BoxcarPrime 150K | – |
| Euro Open NQ | BoxcarFlex 150K or BoxcarPrime 150K | – |
How we calculated
- SRzona trades from a test on tick data, 1 ES contract, $5.74 commission per trade (Boxcar charges $3.50). Data until Oct 30, 2026; the last account start is 60 trading days before the end of the data.
- “Measured”: when price only touches the limit, the order fills in 89% of cases – as measured on our prop accounts. “Worst case”: the order fills only when price trades at least 1 tick through the limit.
- Boxcar Flex: 50% consistency option without a daily loss limit, prices $130 / $215 / $295, payout rules from Oct 26, 2026, end after the 5th payout.
- BluSky Launch: $59 / $69 for every started 21 trading days of the evaluation + $99 / $149 after passing, end at $10,000 total profit.
- SRzona rental: 10 trading days free, then €99 per month (21 trading days) for the first 3 months and €199 after that, €1 = $1.1172, while the account is alive.
- Simulation from Nov 2, 2026, Launch vs Orbit comparison from Nov 5, 2026, prices and rules including account limits and the opposite-position ban checked on the firms' websites on Nov 6, 2026. The firms may change them at any time – check them before you buy.
This is not a recommendation of a specific prop firm or program. Passing the evaluation and receiving a payout are not guaranteed. Hypothetical results have limitations – see the disclosure below.
Prop firms that allow our strategies
Updated November 6, 2026